Music – resisting the streaming model

I thought I’d record here, for posterity, the slightly roundabout way in which I consume music these days. It’s 2025, and I have yet to subscribe to a streaming music service (or TV for that matter) and I have no intention of doing so.
My reasons for this are myriad – as a creator, I don’t believe in the model… I think it’s exploitative to artists and lines the pockets of a small group at the expense of the art and careers of many. (And yet, I put my music up there because you don’t create without wanting to share what you’ve made). I also don’t like the “all you can eat buffet” approach… I’d rather pay for what I consume, and know that most of this goes to the artists.
I don’t know what the answer is. I grew up in the age of cassettes, swapping lovingly crafted mixtapes with friends complete with hand-written commentaries and vocal asides… and social media has (sort of) taken the place of mixtapes, between hand curated playlists and sharing of tracks and videos along with the associated commentary of strangers. Services like Pandora and Spotify can be a wonderful playground for finding more of what you might like, but they can also get things wrong… and for musicians they can’t differentiate between what you listened to for work and for pleasure. And it’s so damned impersonal… which is where the sharing and discussions on social media do things better.
But I still prefer those discussions in person, with real people, and that era of lending each other CDs/records or even lovingly crafting tapes far from cheapening music (as the industry once feared) I think reinforced the its value. If you really liked it, you bought a copy.
The two other main reasons I resist are 1) not wanting to be at the whim of the deals streaming companies make with record companies – it only needs one to go wrong and suddenly a whole load of music you enjoy might become unavailable… even if you are paying X per month. It seems crazy to me that anyone would take the risk. And 2) I’m a musician (and a producer) – and we study music (and recordings) as well as listening to it… and I’d be a fool not to take advantage of the tools available to slow things down, change the key, look at the way something has been mixed.
So… if you’ve made it this far and wonder what I do instead?
It’s a mixed bag that goes onto it but, crazy though it may seem, I put all my music on a NAS. I started digitising my CDs a long time ago, and for most listening… using the lossy ogg vorbis codec is enough. Often I can tag the ripped encoded files from one of the online CDDB, so usually only minor tweaks rather than wholesale typing out of song names! For new and current music, I will buy a download and occasionally even a vinyl. But while the resurgence of vinyl is amazing, I don’t know that it is environmentally sustainable, or the best way to get money in the pockets of the artists you want to support. And… yes I know this will be controversial to some of you, but on the same listening setup, the same mix put onto vinyl is almost always going to lose out to a lossless digital version… especially on repeated listening!
But this brings me onto vinyl… second-hand vinyl which I am enjoying both in terms of musical discovery and rediscovery. There are things I have found on vinyl that aren’t available anywhere else, or are things that would never have been recommended to me by anyone I know, or by any online service – I do love the surprise. And I guess it marks me out as from that generation who would buy a compilation not knowing if it would be a good’un. When I first bought a record player I spoke of the joy of rediscovering music anew that was the soundtrack to books that have stuck with me, and of hearing some of it as though for the first time. This fascination has led to me actively seeking out some records that I had previously only heard on tape or CD – for example Sgt. Pepper… this I heard in mono for the first time the other day and it was a revelation. For many, this was the first they heard of this landmark album, and they enjoyed a tighter more punchy mix than the stereo those of us from a later generation were introduced to. I need to find some time to do a direct comparison…
This has led to me doing something that might be considered mad in some circles, but I’ve been making a digital copy of each record I get hold of – a “needle drop”. These I do a little delicate work on in iZotope RX8 …judicious use of declick (not too much, or you affect the sound, particularly of percussion) – normalise the whole record, then use “find similar” to mark out the track boundaries and save in lossless (FLAC) and ogg vorbis. I can then use Puddletag to grab the track data from Discogs. I’m aware of the perversity when some better known recordings have been remastered with access to the original tapes, better monitoring equipment, and perhaps better trained ears… but I feel I’m hearing these records as they were heard when they were released, and preserving that as I go.
Going back to my music consumption and discovery… our NAS is our sort of “private cloud”. I have a kodi box which uses the NAS as its media source, and it’s plugged into the hi-fi… and any of us in the house can remote control it (using Yatse app) to put music on, put together playlists etc. It might not be the most practical when it comes to feeding the machine and taking music to enjoy on the go, but it suits us. Discovery is “turned off” – there are no distractions telling me other things I might want to check out, just the things we’ve decided we want there. We do still listen to records …even CDs on occasion (though they’re in storage), but we have the convenience of modern technology supplying us most of the time – just not the technology the industry wants us to subscribe to.
Lastly… if you have your CDs or Vinyl and can afford the space to keep hold of them, you really should! At least, if you’re going to listen to them. You won’t get a better listening experience, and while some “improved” releases may be genuine improvements, plenty of remastering for the modern listener compromises the original mix.
